On Wednesday November 18th, the first trial in the murder case of 9 year-old Elizabeth Olten was held at the Cole County Courthouse in Jefferson City. The murder occurred on Wednesday October 21st 2009. 15-year old Alyssa Bustamante, after an 8 am hearing, is charged as an adult with first degree murder and armed criminal action.
I attended the first hearing, no cameras or any recording devices allowed when the judge ruled to charge Bustamante as an adult despite her age. Reasons for this decision included the viciousness and severity of the crime as well as insufficient juvenile services. A second hearing in the afternoon stated her indictment of first degree murder, which by definition is that she committed the murder with prior thoughts and reflection, as well as armed criminal action for her use of a knife in the murder. Since Bustamante did not have a lawyer in the second hearing, there were no cameras or recording devices allowed and the judge pleaded not guilty on her behalf.
The next time the court meets Bustamante will be assigned a public defender and until then she is in the custody of the Cole County Sheriff's Department. After the first hearing, Elizabeth Olten's family was very emotional, however Bustamante showed no emotion at either hearings. The next hearing for this case is December 7th.